The art of performance is one only a select number of modern acts have truly mastered. While it can be easy enough to sing a tune or hit a two-step in front of a crowd, it takes a different level of talent and charisma to really connect with an audience.
Beyoncé’s most recent Christmas Day NFL Halftime performance has, once again, sparked debate as to whether the Destiny’s Child alum is thee best living performer of all time, as she surely connects, has an undeniable stage presence, and a voice that just doesn’t quit, regardless of how hard she’s hittin’ that viral choreo.
While many are obsessed with trying to crown a single performer (Bey, Michael Jackson, etc.) as the GOAT, a survey of top-tier showman throughout the years feels like a more fruitful conversation, as it’s easy to forget those who paved the way and were, relative to their time, just as iconic. Comparing artists of different eras is always tricky, as technological advancements and broader fanbases make it difficult to really asses. After all, who knows what Little Richard would’ve done with pyrotechnics?
Considerations include stage presence, costuming, technical singing/playing and dancing ability, creativity of presentation, and overall entertainment value. And just FYI, this list will not include rappers, as the metrics for a great Hip-Hop show are slightly different and warrants its own list.
Check out VIBE’s list of our greatest performers, decade-by-decade, below.
-
1950s – Little Richard
Image Credit: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images The late Little Richard was among musical greats like Chuck Berry and Ike Turner in founding and bringing Rock ‘N Roll to the masses. While Berry impressed with his beloved guitar and Turner largely relied on his talented wife to command the stage, the “Good Golly Miss Molly” artist took performance to a new level himself with his thunderous piano style, electrifying stage presence, and awe-inspiring wardrobe that reflected his own eclectic style and personality, going on to influence literally everyone to follow on this list.
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: Chuck Berry, Jackie Wilson, Elvis Presley.
-
1960s – Tina Turner And James Brown
Image Credit: Photo by Gilles Petard/Redferns If we’re talking stage presence, there were no two names bigger in the 1960s than Tina Turner and James Brown. Turner and her one-of-a-kind, raspy, rock-infused voice commanded the crowd while her moves, charisma, sex appeal, and iconic wardrobe mesmerized anyone within eye-sight.
[youtube
James Brown also ruled the decade, and with nicknames like “Mr. Dynamite” and “The Hardest Working Man In Show Business,” it was clear that he was something special up on that stage. From his command of his band — and the room — to his soul-stirring vocals, to his blink-and-you’ll miss it footwork, Brown became the standard for male performers and went on to influence many generations, including the icon many consider to be the greatest performer of all time.
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: The Temptations, Otis Redding.
-
1970s – The Jackson 5
Image Credit: Fin Costello/Redferns. While James Brown continued to give fans earth-shattering performances into the 70s, Joe and Katherine’s kids would soon rise as the premiere stage attraction of the decade.
Under father Joe Jackson’s management, The Jackson 5 — later The Jacksons — cut their teeth with various talent shows before hitting the chitlin circuit, and eventually, venues like Chicago’s Regal Theater and Harlem’s Apollo Theater, where their impeccable showmanship was put on full display. From Tito’s prowess on the guitar to Michael’s precocious vocal talents to the entire group’s charisma and charm, catching these brothers tear down the stage was always an epic event.
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: Stevie Wonder, Donna Summer, Earth, Wind & Fire.
-
1980s – Michael Jackson
Image Credit: Kevin Mazur/WireImage) I mean, what is there to say?
Widely considered the greatest performer of all time, Michael Jackson‘s 1980s reign is still the bar by which superstars are measured. His impeccable moves, — including his signature moonwalk — powerful pipes, iconic wardrobe, elaborate stage production and the overall WOW factor of his shows is something few have been able to emulate in the 40 years since. There’s good, and there’s “grown men passing out at the sight of you” good, and Michael, regardless of where he was in the world, was the latter. We’re talking ambulances on stand-by as he soars through the air, knowing his presence and stage show is just that electrifying.
While the 1980s were undeniably his heyday, Jackson’s performances continued to impress into the 1990s, paving the way for a younger sibling who picked up more than a few pointers from her beloved big bro.
[youtube
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: Prince, Tina Turner, New Edition, Bobby Brown (solo).
-
1990s – Janet Jackson
Image Credit: Raymond Boyd/Getty Images Just as her big bro did the decade prior, Janet Jackson solidified herself as thee top performer of the 1990s, largely thanks to the timeless choreography featured within her legendary 1990 Rhythm Nation World Tour. The janet. World Tour (which ran from November 1993 to April 1995 over an impressive six legs) and 1998s The Velvet Rope Tour followed, producing some of the most buzzworthy performances of the era. This includes Janet’s signature move of bringing a lucky man up on stage for a strapped-down, intimate tease as she softly coos “Would You Mind” and “Any Time, Any Place,” a move that has been emulated by artists like Destiny’s Child and Teyana Taylor.
[youtube
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: TLC, Ginuwine, Usher.
-
2000s – Beyoncé
Image Credit: Tim Mosenfelder/Getty Images Beyoncé broke out as a solo star in the early 2000s, and has been on an epic run ever since. While she’s been praised for many aspects of her performances — from stunning costumes to viral choreography — Bey’s ability to sound just as good or better live than on her studio albums is what universally impresses. The same cannot be said for other performers who, while great dancers or fantastic vocalists, cannot combine the two at 100% in a live setting, something Bey and only few others of her generation have mastered.
[youtube
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: Usher, Ciara, Jill Scott.
-
2010s – Bruno Mars, Beyoncé, And Chris Brown
Image Credit: Getty Images We tried, and I mean really tried, to narrow this down, but we just couldn’t short any of these incredible talents.
Beyoncé continued her reign into the 2010s with her The Mrs. Carter Show and The Formation World Tours, where she was praised for her addictive choreography and live vocal chops, just as she was when she hit the Super Bowl halftime show in both 2013 and 2016. Her biggest performance of the decade — and perhaps her career — came with 2018s “Beychella,” her headlining Coachella gig that was documented by Netflix for her Homecoming: A Film by Beyoncé doc, which earned the star a Grammy for Best Music Film. That “Everybody Mad” choreo also had us in a chokehold.
[youtube
Bruno Mars also established himself as an undeniable showman throughout the 2010s. Incorporating New Jack Swing vibes throughout his stage shows provided a sense is nostalgia while his high-energy, infectious smile, powerful pipes and stage presence left an impression on the masses via his own tours and on various award shows.
[youtube
Finally, we must acknowledge the stage-killer known as Chris Brown, as Breezy’s performances were some of the most exciting and unexpected of the decade. From gravity-defying dance moves to that good ol’ R&B beggin, Brown respects his audience enough to give them their money’s worth, leaving his heart on the floor every single time. Like Bey, Chris sounds just as good live as he does on the record, despite hitting complex dance moves throughout the show. That stamina is the stuff of greats, and Brown is undoubtedly in that category when it come to live performers. We’d even argue that, if given that same opportunities as his peers, his status as one of the GOATs would be unquestionable, and for those of us who can remain objective in this analysis, it is.
Not to mention, fans are still amazed at that 2016 “March Madness” front flip, a single moment that’s had us at attention ever since.
[youtube
Notable contemporaries: Janelle Monaé, Teyana Taylor.
-
2020-Present – Usher and Beyoncé
Image Credit: Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for Roc Nation) If we’re talking 2020 to present, Usher Raymond IV is the man to beat when it comes to breaking it down onstage.
The showman has been a top-tier performer since the 1990s, but separated himself from the pack with his 2021 Las Vegas Residency, which was extended multiple times due to high-demand. Incorporating everything from skate culture to his beloved Atlanta strip clubs into the show, Usher provided an unforgettable experience in Sin City that highlighted his natural talents and love for R&B. This landed him the highly-coveted Super Bowl halftime show in 2024, where he went all out with the moves, costumes, special guests, and a set list that satisfied both his loyal R&B following and pop fans screaming “Oh My God!” at the sight of his impeccable performance.
[youtube
Bey’s consistency also places her as a top-tier performer for the third decade in a row, leaving fans in awe during her Renaissance World Tour and, most recently, her performance of Cowboy Carter hits at the Texans vs Ravens Christmas game. The showcase was so impressive, that it stirred the conversation that inspired this very list, with many deeming Bey the greatest living performer of all time.
[youtube
That said, we’re only halfway through the decade, meaning any number of artists can rise to the top between 2025 and 2029. Only time will tell who truly rules the era, but for now, it seems like we’re in good hands with the Atlanta crooner and the Houston diva giving us everything we need.
Notable contemporaries: Chris Brown, Doja Cat, The Weeknd.
Leave a comment