Whether it’s a scorned woman dragging her cheating husband out of bed (Diary of a Mad Black Woman), a lonely mother scammed and humiliated by a younger lover (A Fall From Grace), or a bitter wife who loses everything after building a man from scratch (Acrimony), pain is the constant pulse that runs through Perry’s work.
And not just any pain, Black pain. The kind that’s loud, aching, generational. The kind we whisper about in family circles and shout about in Sunday service.
But why does it work? Why does Tyler Perry, despite constant criticism from academics, feminists, and cinephiles, still rake in millions at the box office and top the streaming charts?
Because pain sells. Especially when it’s Black.
ALSO READ: ‘They’re trying to erase us, keep leaving footprints’ – Tyler Perry gets real at BET Awards
A brand built on struggle
Perry has built an empire on trauma. The blueprint is unmistakable: a broken woman, usually poor, betrayed by her partner, rejected by the world, abandoned by the system.
She may find healing (usually via Jesus or a God-fearing man), or she may die. Either way, the story lingers in the wound.
His 2020 Netflix release A Fall From Grace drew widespread backlash for its poor production quality, but it was also one of the most-watched films on the platform globally during its release week. Similarly, Straw, his latest project starring Taraji P. Henson, is once again drenched in darkness: poverty, betrayal, prison, loneliness. And guess what? It’s a hit.
Perry knows his audience. He knows their traumas, some of which mirror his own. He understands what it means to grow up in a house where violence and survival shaped your every decision. He’s said it himself: “People relate to pain more than anything.”
But is it time to question why that’s all we seem to relate to?
RECOMMENDED: 10 Tyler Perry films every aspiring Nigerian filmmaker should study
The politics of Black suffering
Tyler Perry is not the first to mine trauma for storytelling. Black art has long centered pain because historically, pain has always been part of the Black experience. From slavery to segregation, from police brutality to economic disenfranchisement, Black life has often meant making poetry out of grief.
But there is a difference between documenting trauma and recycling it as entertainment.
In Perry’s world, pain isn’t just a narrative device, it’s the entire plot. Characters don’t grow through struggle; they exist solely within it. Women are cheated on, beaten, ridiculed. Men are either saviours or sociopaths. Redemption comes only after the world has chewed you up and spat you out.
Critics have argued that this continuous depiction reinforces a singular image of Blackness: one steeped in hardship, morality, and salvation through suffering. Where are the stories of Black joy, leisure, or mediocrity? Where are the messy, complex, unremarkable lives? Not every Black story needs a cross to carry.
ALSO READ: If you loved Tyler Perry’s ‘Straw,’ then you’ll enjoy these other Tyler Perry movies
But why does it still work
So why does the pain keep selling? Why do millions still watch?
1. Familiarity: Many Black viewers have seen pieces of themselves or their families in Perry’s characters. The abusive uncle, the absent father, the prayerful grandmother, the cousin who never recovered from heartbreak, they’re all recognizable. There’s catharsis in recognition, even if the depiction is flawed.
2. Spirituality: Christianity is deeply woven into Perry’s storytelling. His characters cry out to God, find solace in scripture, and are often “delivered” through divine intervention. This appeals to a large, faith-rooted demographic that sees spiritual warfare mirrored in their own lives.
3. Representation, however limited: For decades, Black stories were either sidelined or erased in mainstream media. Perry’s work, flawed as it may be, put Black faces, voices, and bodies on screen consistently. To many, that mattered more than critical acclaim.
4. Market conditioning: The industry itself has often rewarded stories rooted in Black trauma. From 12 Years a Slave to The Color Purple, award-winning narratives about Black people often lean toward pain. This creates a cycle where trauma becomes the safest, most profitable version of Blackness to market.
EXPLORE THIS: Tyler Perry faces lawsuit over Netflix series ‘She The People’
This is a larger industry problem
To blame Perry alone is to ignore the larger issue. Hollywood, and even Nollywood has long commodified Black trauma. Whether it’s the slave epic, the inner-city struggle film, or the “Black woman crying in the mirror” genre, there is a formula. And audiences, knowingly or not, have consumed it for years.
What Perry has done is package it for mass consumption. Slick marketing, recognisable stars, and just enough redemption to keep it hopeful. He didn’t invent trauma storytelling, he just perfected the algorithm.
Leave a comment